Link Totals Mislead: Four of 11 Directories Have 300+ Backlinks per Referring Domain, and Authority Score, Not Link Count, Lined Up With Who Kept Their Google Traffic

Disclosure
This article is promotional content produced as part of the Semrush Creator Accelerator programme. It contains affiliate links to Semrush — if you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you — and we may also receive a reward from Semrush for publishing it. The data comes from Semrush's own database: we queried its backlink overview through the Semrush MCP connector on 18 November 2026. We chose the sites, the method and the conclusions; Semrush did not review or approve them.
When you size up a competitor's links, the first number most tools show is the total: millions of backlinks, sometimes tens of millions. It is a big, easy number, and it can say very little about how strong a link profile is.
So we took twelve directories and asked a narrower question. What does a directory's link profile consist of, and which number, if any, lines up with the sites that kept their Google traffic? For the traffic side we use the one-year change in Semrush's traffic estimate from our earlier look at these directories.
Read the profile, not the total
Backlink Analytics in the SEO Toolkit breaks a domain's links into referring domains, follow and nofollow, sponsored and Authority Score. To follow whether AI answers cite you as well, the AI Visibility Toolkit is part of Semrush One: try Semrush One free for 7 days.
What we pulled
The twelve are ten AI tool directories (theresanaiforthat.com, futurepedia.io, toolify.ai, topai.tools, aixploria.com, dang.ai, opentools.ai, futuretools.io, aitoolhunt.com and easywithai.com) and two long-running software directories, saashub.com and alternativeto.net. For each root domain, Semrush's Backlink Analytics overview gave us Authority Score, total backlinks, referring domains, follow, nofollow, sponsored and user-generated links, as they stood on 18 November 2026.
One of the twelve, aitoolhunt.com, no longer serves a directory: a request to its home page redirected to an unrelated site on 18 November. Its Authority Score in Semrush is 5, even though Semrush still lists 5,038 referring domains pointing at it. We show it in the table and leave it out of the comparisons, which cover the other 11.
A few domains write most of the links
Take each directory's total backlinks and divide by its referring domains. The median is 31 links per referring domain, but the range runs from 10 to 1,916. Four of the 11 have 300 or more: alternativeto.net (1,916), saashub.com (537), theresanaiforthat.com (430) and dang.ai (319).
A ratio like that means the average linking site links many times, from many pages or from a footer or sidebar; we did not check which. alternativeto.net's 84,964,122 backlinks come from 44,337 domains, and the next largest total, saashub.com's, is 9,249,230. A total that large says how often sites link, not how many sites do.
Half the links are nofollow, and one profile is a third sponsored
Six of the 11 have more nofollow than follow links, and the median nofollow share is 49.8%. It ranges from 0.5% at alternativeto.net to 79.2% at aixploria.com.
Sponsored links are rarer, with one exception. Semrush classifies 31% of saashub.com's backlinks as sponsored (2,870,613 of 9,249,230 links), and 10.2% of topai.tools's. That is how the linking pages are labelled, which says nothing about who paid for them. For the other nine, sponsored links are 1.1% or less.
Authority Score lined up with who kept traffic
We ranked the 11 active directories on each link measure and on their one-year change in estimated traffic, and compared the rankings (Spearman).
- Authority Score: 0.71.
- Referring domains: 0.44.
- Nofollow share of links: -0.36.
The six directories with an Authority Score of 42 or more had a median traffic change of -8.5%, and three of them grew. The five at 40 or below had a median of -66.4%, and one grew (dang.ai, at 135.4%).
That is a pattern across eleven sites, not proof. Our link figures are from today, so a directory that kept its traffic may simply have kept its links, and its authority, because of it. Semrush's Authority Score is a modelled measure, and its traffic figure is an estimate. We can say which numbers moved together, not which came first.
Site by site
| Directory | Authority Score | Referring domains | Backlinks per referring domain | Nofollow share | Sponsored share | Traffic estimate, 1-year change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| alternativeto.net | 59 | 44,337 | 1,916 | 0.5% | 0% | +10.5% |
| theresanaiforthat.com | 52 | 16,503 | 430 | 59.9% | 0% | +34.3% |
| toolify.ai | 44 | 9,555 | 51 | 49.5% | 0% | -39.2% |
| aixploria.com | 43 | 4,498 | 22 | 79.2% | 1.1% | +21.3% |
| saashub.com | 42 | 17,215 | 537 | 41.1% | 31% | -34.5% |
| futuretools.io | 42 | 6,141 | 23 | 49.8% | 0.1% | -27.5% |
| dang.ai | 40 | 9,674 | 319 | 9.6% | 0.6% | +135.4% |
| futurepedia.io | 39 | 7,706 | 22 | 61.9% | 0.1% | -50.8% |
| opentools.ai | 39 | 7,981 | 10 | 48.2% | 0.2% | -66.4% |
| easywithai.com | 36 | 5,199 | 14 | 66% | 0% | -86.5% |
| topai.tools | 35 | 4,926 | 31 | 72.4% | 10.2% | -98.4% |
| aitoolhunt.com | 5 | 5,038 | 32 | 13.6% | 0% | -100% |
How to read a competitor's links
- Divide the total by the referring domains. A figure in the hundreds means a few sites supply most of the links. Count the domains, not the links.
- Compare Authority Score, then the domain count. Here the first lined up with traffic changes more closely than the second.
- Check the follow, nofollow and sponsored split before you copy anyone's links. A profile that is mostly nofollow or sponsored passes a different signal from one that is almost all follow.
- Look at who links, not just how many. Two profiles with the same domain count can come from very different sites.
Doing it in Semrush
See one domain's links in full. Backlink Analytics reports referring domains, backlinks, Authority Score and the follow and nofollow split for a domain, and lists each referring domain with its own Authority Score, category and first and last seen dates.

Find the sites that link to your competitors and not to you. Backlink Gap, in the SEO Toolkit, compares your link profile with competitors' and lists the domains that link to them.

Follow what happens to your own rankings. Position Tracking monitors the keywords you choose daily, so you can see whether a new link moves a ranking.
Semrush One includes the SEO Toolkit and the AI Visibility Toolkit, and the 7-day free trial belongs to Semrush One. To compare your own link profile with your competitors' before paying, try Semrush One free for 7 days. Semrush's product page describes the offer as "Unlimited access to all Semrush One tools" (read on 16 October 2026). The numbers in this article came from Semrush's database through its MCP connector, not from the trial.

A big total is not a strong profile
Across these eleven directories, link volume was driven by a few repeat linkers, half the links carried no follow signal, and the number that lined up best with traffic was Authority Score. Before you measure yourself against a competitor's link count, measure how many different sites it comes from.
Try Semrush One free for 7 days
Compare backlink profiles in Backlink Analytics and follow AI citations in the AI Visibility Toolkit, both included in Semrush One. Free for 7 days for new users.
Try Semrush One free for 7 daysHow we counted
- Source: Semrush Backlink Analytics overview (the
backlinks_overviewreport), root-domain level, queried on 18 November 2026 through the Semrush MCP connector: one row per directory. - Fields: Authority Score; total backlinks; referring domains; follow, nofollow, sponsored and user-generated backlinks.
- Derived: backlinks per referring domain is total backlinks divided by referring domains. Nofollow and sponsored shares are those counts divided by total backlinks. Semrush's follow, nofollow and sponsored counts can overlap (for topai.tools they add up to 9.8% more than its total), so we show each share on its own and never add them together. We also pulled its user-generated count but do not use it.
- Traffic change: the one-year change in Semrush's estimated US desktop traffic, October 2025 to October 2026, from the same 12 directories (see the earlier article). The rank correlation uses the 11 active directories.
- Aitoolhunt.com: a request to its home page on 18 November 2026 redirected to an unrelated site. We show it in the table and left it out of the comparisons.
- Limits: 12 sites chosen by us, not every directory; one snapshot of links, so we cannot tell whether links or traffic moved first; Authority Score and traffic are Semrush's estimates; we did not check who the linking sites are.
- Reproduce it: the scripts and saved results are in
research/r2-i3-directory-links/.
Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Related Articles
Explore more guides and reviews from our experts.

AI Tool Home Pages Redirect to HTTPS 94.5% of the Time, but Only 63% Send HSTS, 35% a Content-Security-Policy and 6% All Six Basic Security Headers: We Checked 601

Insightful Pricing (2026): Three Plans, a 50-Seat Minimum and a 14-Day Work Audit
