Skip to content

AI Overviews or Lost Rankings? On 20 Content Sites, AI Overviews Reached 93.9% of Their Keywords While Their Top-3 Rankings Fell 39.2% in a Year

Sohail Akhtar
Researched by Sohail AkhtarTheToolsVerse
November 17, 20268 min read
Median of 20 large content sites in Semrush US data: keywords with an AI Overview rose from 10.7% in October 2024 to 93.9% in October 2026, while keywords in the top 3 fell to 35 and the traffic estimate to 42 (October 2024 = 100).

Disclosure

This article is promotional content produced as part of the Semrush Creator Accelerator programme. It contains affiliate links to Semrush — if you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you — and we may also receive a reward from Semrush for publishing it. The data comes from Semrush's own database: we queried its domain history through the Semrush MCP connector on 17 November 2026. We chose the sites, the method and the conclusions; Semrush did not review or approve them.

When organic traffic falls now, AI Overviews get the blame first. Often that is fair. But a site that slips from #2 to #7 produces the same falling line in a traffic report, and the fix for that is different.

So we looked at both at once. For 20 large content sites we pulled two years of Semrush's monthly domain history and compared the same month each year: how many of their ranking keywords show an AI Overview, and how many of their keywords still rank in the top 3?

Count your top-3 keywords before you blame the AI Overview

Position Tracking follows your rankings daily and can track the AI Overview as a SERP feature next to them. To see whether AI answers cite you across Google, ChatGPT and Gemini, the AI Visibility Toolkit is part of Semrush One: try Semrush One free for 7 days.

The 20 sites

We chose large, mostly informational sites across 11 niches: nerdwallet.com and bankrate.com (finance), webmd.com, verywellhealth.com and medicalnewstoday.com (health), howtogeek.com, lifewire.com and makeuseof.com (tech how-to), foodnetwork.com and simplyrecipes.com (food), bhg.com and familyhandyman.com (home), tripsavvy.com and cntraveler.com (travel), merriam-webster.com (reference), thoughtco.com (education), neilpatel.com and backlinko.com (marketing), akc.org (pets) and caranddriver.com (cars).

For each one, Semrush's US domain history gave us, month by month: the keywords it ranks for, the keywords it ranks for in positions 1 to 3, Semrush's traffic estimate, the ranking keywords whose results page shows an AI Overview, and the keywords where the site itself appears in the AI Overview. We compare October 2024, October 2025 and October 2026, so seasons do not distort the change.

AI Overviews went from one keyword in ten to nine in ten

For the median site, the share of its ranking keywords with an AI Overview on the results page was 10.7% in October 2024, 53.5% in October 2025 and 93.9% in October 2026. In October 2026, 11 of the 20 sites were above 90%, and the lowest, cntraveler.com, was at 66.2%.

For 17 of the 20 sites, the biggest one-month rise in Semrush's records came between February and March 2025, when the median share went from 15.1% to 31.2%. By July 2025 it was past half, at 51.6%.

Their top-3 rankings fell at the same time

Over the past year, the median site's keywords in the top 3 fell by 39.2%. Nineteen of the 20 lost top-3 rankings; over two years, all 20 did, by a median 65%. The one site that gained over the last year, cntraveler.com, more than doubled its top-3 keywords (+120.4%).

AI Overviews spread while top-3 rankings fell. Median of 20 large content sites, Semrush US data: keywords with an AI Overview were 10.7% of ranking keywords in October 2024, 53.5% in October 2025 and 93.9% in October 2026; keywords in the top 3 fell from 100 to 62 to 35, and the traffic estimate from 100 to 59 to 42 (October 2024 = 100).
AI Overviews spread while top-3 rankings fell. Median of 20 large content sites, Semrush US data: keywords with an AI Overview were 10.7% of ranking keywords in October 2024, 53.5% in October 2025 and 93.9% in October 2026; keywords in the top 3 fell from 100 to 62 to 35, and the traffic estimate from 100 to 59 to 42 (October 2024 = 100).

The traffic estimate moved with the rankings

Semrush's traffic estimate for the median site fell 38.3% over the past year and 58.1% over two years. Thirteen of the 20 lost at least half of their estimated traffic since October 2024.

Across the 20 sites, the change in estimated traffic follows the change in top-3 keywords closely: a rank correlation of 0.881. Its link to how fast AI Overviews spread over each site's keywords is much weaker, 0.362. Not one site lost estimated traffic over the past year while its top-3 count grew.

That close fit is partly built in, and it is the most useful thing in this data. Semrush estimates traffic from where a site ranks and how often those keywords are searched. A traffic estimate can show a ranking loss. It cannot show clicks that an AI Overview took from a ranking that held. For that, you need your own click data next to your rankings.

Being cited in the answer: about one keyword in 20

Across all of a site's ranking keywords that show an AI Overview, the median site was cited in the AI Overview for 4.8% of them in October 2025 and 4.7% in October 2026. The rate went up for 14 of the 20 sites, so the flat median hides movement in both directions:

  • akc.org went from 10.5% to 17.1%, and merriam-webster.com from 13.3% to 16.5%.
  • backlinko.com fell from 7.3% to 0.9%.
  • caranddriver.com fell from 8.5% to 0%: Semrush recorded it in 146,735 AI Overviews in October 2025 and in 744 in October 2026, with most of the drop in December 2025. We did not investigate why.

Site by site

SiteNicheKeywords with an AI Overview, Oct 2025 → Oct 2026Top-3 keywords, 1-year changeTraffic estimate, 1-year change
nerdwallet.comfinance51.9% → 94.3%-53.9%-36.3%
bankrate.comfinance52.9% → 94.1%-39.7%-31.9%
webmd.comhealth63.5% → 76.8%-54.3%-55.8%
verywellhealth.comhealth79.4% → 98.3%-62.2%-71.5%
medicalnewstoday.comhealth75% → 94.1%-66.1%-68%
howtogeek.comtech how-to63.6% → 96.1%-31.9%-18.7%
lifewire.comtech how-to68.9% → 96.2%-72.1%-55.1%
makeuseof.comtech how-to64.9% → 95.7%-23.4%+36.4%
foodnetwork.comfood31.6% → 76.3%-23.4%+0.5%
simplyrecipes.comfood36.2% → 82.1%-65.1%-55.5%
bhg.comhome48% → 83.4%-78.6%-72.2%
familyhandyman.comhome50.8% → 88.6%-46.6%-50.4%
tripsavvy.comtravel43.1% → 74%-20.4%+5.9%
cntraveler.comtravel28.9% → 66.2%+120.4%+86.2%
merriam-webster.comreference39% → 94.4%-6.2%+30.2%
thoughtco.comeducation65.9% → 93.7%-35.3%-44.7%
neilpatel.commarketing57.4% → 96.4%-29.6%-19%
backlinko.commarketing56.1% → 96.7%-78.6%-51.5%
akc.orgpets54.1% → 84.7%-38.6%-25.1%
caranddriver.comcars46.6% → 80%-21.1%-40.4%

How to tell which one hit you

  1. Count your top-3 keywords month by month, for the same month a year apart. If that count fell, part of your drop is a ranking problem, whatever the AI Overviews did.
  2. Put your own clicks next to it. Take the clicks from Search Console for the keywords where you held your position. If clicks fell while the ranking held, that is the click an AI Overview, or another feature above you, took.
  3. Check which of your keywords show an AI Overview, and whether it cites you. On these sites, about one in 20 did. A cited page is worth protecting; an uncited one under an AI Overview is the content to rework or retire.
  4. Fix rankings first where you can. A lost top-3 position costs clicks with or without an AI Overview, and it is the part you have most control over.

Doing it in Semrush

Track rankings and the AI Overview together. Position Tracking in the SEO Toolkit monitors your keywords daily and lets you choose SERP features to track, AI Overview among them.

Semrush's own illustration of the SERP features menu in Position Tracking, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 29 October 2026): options to track Local pack, Hotels, AI Overview and Jobs for a tracked domain. Semrush's illustration, not our account.
Semrush's own illustration of the SERP features menu in Position Tracking, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 29 October 2026): options to track Local pack, Hotels, AI Overview and Jobs for a tracked domain. Semrush's illustration, not our account.

See search and AI visibility side by side. Domain Overview shows a site's organic traffic and referring domains next to an AI Search panel for ChatGPT, AI Overview, AI Mode and Gemini. Organic Rankings, also in the SEO Toolkit, holds the history this article is built on.

Semrush's own illustration of Domain Overview, from its AI visibility features Knowledge Base page (retrieved 17 October 2026): an AI Search panel with AI visibility, mentions and cited pages for ChatGPT, AI Overview, AI Mode and Gemini, beside the SEO panel with Authority Score, organic traffic and referring domains. Semrush's illustration, not our account.
Semrush's own illustration of Domain Overview, from its AI visibility features Knowledge Base page (retrieved 17 October 2026): an AI Search panel with AI visibility, mentions and cited pages for ChatGPT, AI Overview, AI Mode and Gemini, beside the SEO panel with Authority Score, organic traffic and referring domains. Semrush's illustration, not our account.

Find what to write instead. Topic Research maps subtopics, headlines and questions around a subject, a starting point for pages built on your own experience rather than on facts an AI Overview can summarise.

Semrush's own illustration of Topic Research's Mind Map view, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 14 October 2026): subtopics radiating from a central topic, with headlines and a Questions panel filterable by What, How, Is and Why. Semrush's illustration, not our account.
Semrush's own illustration of Topic Research's Mind Map view, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 14 October 2026): subtopics radiating from a central topic, with headlines and a Questions panel filterable by What, How, Is and Why. Semrush's illustration, not our account.

Clear the technical problems before you prune. Site Audit sorts issues into categories including Crawlability and AI Search, with how to fix each one.

Semrush's own illustration of Site Audit's issues list, from its Site Audit feature page (retrieved 29 October 2026): errors, warnings and notices filtered into categories including Crawlability and AI Search, with an "About the issue / How to fix" panel. Semrush's illustration, not our site.
Semrush's own illustration of Site Audit's issues list, from its Site Audit feature page (retrieved 29 October 2026): errors, warnings and notices filtered into categories including Crawlability and AI Search, with an "About the issue / How to fix" panel. Semrush's illustration, not our site.

Follow your citations over time. The AI Visibility Toolkit reports mentions and cited pages across AI platforms, month by month.

Semrush's own illustration of Visibility Overview, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 14 October 2026): an eyewear brand's AI Visibility score of 36 out of 100, mentions and cited pages over six months, and the date menu that loads historical data by month. Semrush's illustration, not our account.
Semrush's own illustration of Visibility Overview, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 14 October 2026): an eyewear brand's AI Visibility score of 36 out of 100, mentions and cited pages over six months, and the date menu that loads historical data by month. Semrush's illustration, not our account.

Semrush One includes the SEO Toolkit and the AI Visibility Toolkit, and the 7-day free trial belongs to Semrush One. To pull the same history for your own site before paying, try Semrush One free for 7 days. Semrush's product page describes the offer as "Unlimited access to all Semrush One tools" (read on 16 October 2026). The numbers in this article came from Semrush's database through its MCP connector, not from the trial.

Semrush One's own product page: "Try free for 7 days" button with "Unlimited access to all Semrush One tools" beneath it. Captured from Semrush's page on 26 September 2026; the same wording was live on 16 October 2026.
Semrush One's own product page: "Try free for 7 days" button with "Unlimited access to all Semrush One tools" beneath it. Captured from Semrush's page on 26 September 2026; the same wording was live on 16 October 2026.
Semrush's official Semrush One graphic, from the Semrush Creator Accelerator affiliate resources: "Semrush One" at the centre of ten capabilities, including AI + SEO Visibility, Site Health + AI Search Auditing, AI Brand Narrative and Share of Voice. Semrush's own image.
Semrush's official Semrush One graphic, from the Semrush Creator Accelerator affiliate resources: "Semrush One" at the centre of ten capabilities, including AI + SEO Visibility, Site Health + AI Search Auditing, AI Brand Narrative and Share of Voice. Semrush's own image.

Two explanations, one chart

On these 20 sites, the AI Overview arrived and the top-3 rankings left in the same two years. Measure them separately, or you will fix the wrong one.

Try Semrush One free for 7 days

Track rankings and AI Overviews together in Position Tracking, and citations across AI platforms in the AI Visibility Toolkit, both included in Semrush One. Free for 7 days for new users.

Try Semrush One free for 7 days

How we counted

  • Source: Semrush domain history (the resource_rank_history report), US database, queried on 17 November 2026 through the Semrush MCP connector: 25 monthly rows per site, October 2024 to October 2026.
  • Columns: organic keywords; keywords in positions 1 to 3; organic traffic (Semrush's estimate); ranking keywords whose results page shows an AI Overview; keywords where the site appears in the AI Overview.
  • AI Overview share: keywords with an AI Overview divided by all ranking keywords, per site, then the median across sites.
  • Cited rate: keywords where the site appears in the AI Overview divided by keywords with an AI Overview.
  • Changes: the same month a year (or two) apart, per site, then the median. Index values in the chart are each site's figure divided by its October 2024 figure, then the median.
  • Rank correlation: Spearman, across the 20 sites, between one-year changes.
  • Why top 3, not all keywords: total keyword counts in rank trackers shift with how deep they can see into results, so we lean on the top 3, which those changes affect least. Semrush's database itself can still change over time.
  • Limits: 20 sites chosen by us, not a sample of the web; one database (US); traffic is Semrush's estimate, not the sites' own analytics; we did not check any site's clicks.
  • Reproduce it: the scripts and saved results are in research/r2-g2-traffic-cliff/.

Explore More AI Tools

Browse our curated directory of 855+ verified AI tools.

Browse Directory

Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.