Skip to content

We Re-Checked 2,098 URLs That Five AI Engines Cited: 91.6% Still Load, 0.8% Are Gone, and 7.7% Cannot Be Verified by a Bot

Sohail Akhtar
Researched by Sohail AkhtarTheToolsVerse
November 15, 20268 min read
Do AI citations still load? Of 2,098 URLs cited by five AI engines on 24 October 2026, 91.6% loaded on 13 November, 0.8% were gone or redirected to a home page, and 7.7% could not be verified by an automated check.

Disclosure

This article is promotional content produced as part of the Semrush Creator Accelerator programme. It contains affiliate links to Semrush — if you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you — and we may also receive a reward from Semrush for publishing it. All measurements in this article are our own. Semrush did not supply, review or approve the data, and the conclusions we draw are ours.

AI visibility is now reported in citations: how often your pages are cited, which pages, and how that changes over time. A citation is only a useful unit if the page it points to still exists, so before building a KPI on it we wanted to know how clean the unit is.

We took the pages that five AI engines cited three weeks ago and visited every one of them again.

See which of your pages AI cites

Track the pages that AI platforms cite for your brand and your competitors with Visibility Overview in the AI Visibility Toolkit. To get it with the SEO Toolkit in one subscription, try Semrush One free for 7 days.

The test

On 24 October 2026 we asked 88 questions about AI tools and software (buyer questions such as where to submit a tool, which tool to pick, and how two tools compare) on five engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini and Google AI Mode. That gave 440 answers and 2,684 citations, which come to 2,098 unique URLs on 1,280 domains. Of those, 253 URLs were cited by more than one engine.

On 13 November 2026, 20 days later, we requested every one of the 2,098 URLs, following up to five redirects. Any URL that did not load on the first pass was tried again with a second, independent HTTP client (curl, which has a different TLS stack and headers). We put each URL in one group:

  • Loads: the page answers with a success status.
  • Gone: the page returns 404 or 410, and both clients agree.
  • Sent to a home page: the cited page redirects to a bare home page. The page may have moved or been removed; we cannot tell which.
  • Refused: the site answered but refused an automated request (401, 402, 403, 406 or 429).
  • No answer or error: no response, a timeout, a refused connection or a server error.

Nine in ten still load

What happened to the URLURLsShare of 2,098
Loads1,92191.6%
Gone (404 or 410)120.6%
Sent to a home page40.2%
Refused an automated check733.5%
No answer854.1%
Server error30.1%

91.6% of the cited URLs still load. 0.8% (16) are gone or redirect to a home page, and 7.7% (161) could not be verified at all, because the site refused an automated check or never answered.

The unverified group is the one to keep in mind. We did not count it as dead. Our first pass listed more pages as gone than the second client agreed with, and a spot check showed that some of them load normally in a browser-like request. The 16 pages in the table are the ones both clients agree on.

It barely differs by engine

Do the pages AI cites still load? Status of the URLs cited by five engines, checked 13 November 2026, answers captured 24 October 2026. All 2,098 unique URLs: 91.6% load, 0.8% gone or sent to a home page, 3.5% refused an automated check, 4.2% no answer or error. By engine, the share gone or sent to a home page was 0.9% for ChatGPT (797 citations), 0.8% for Perplexity (873), 0.6% for Claude (494), 0.7% for Gemini (286) and 0% for Google AI Mode (234).
Do the pages AI cites still load? Status of the URLs cited by five engines, checked 13 November 2026, answers captured 24 October 2026. All 2,098 unique URLs: 91.6% load, 0.8% gone or sent to a home page, 3.5% refused an automated check, 4.2% no answer or error. By engine, the share gone or sent to a home page was 0.9% for ChatGPT (797 citations), 0.8% for Perplexity (873), 0.6% for Claude (494), 0.7% for Gemini (286) and 0% for Google AI Mode (234).

Per citation, the share that is gone or redirected away is 0.9% for ChatGPT, 0.8% for Perplexity, 0.7% for Gemini, 0.6% for Claude and 0% for Google AI Mode. Those are 7, 7, 2, 3 and 0 URLs, which is too few to rank the engines. The honest reading is that none of them stood out.

At the level of a whole answer the picture looks different, but for a mechanical reason:

EngineCitations per answerAnswers with at least one gone or redirected-away citation
Perplexity9.98.0% (7 of 88)
ChatGPT9.18.0% (7 of 88)
Claude5.63.4% (3 of 88)
Gemini3.32.3% (2 of 88)
Google AI Mode2.70% (0 of 88)

The more links an answer cites, the more likely one of them is dead. Perplexity and ChatGPT cite more than three times as many links per answer as Google AI Mode, and roughly one answer in twelve from either carried at least one link that no longer reached its page.

What kind of page goes missing?

We grouped the URLs by their address. Comparison pages (an address containing "vs", "compare" or "alternative") were gone or redirected away in 6 of 433 cases (1.4%), best-of lists in 3 of 575 (0.5%), other pages in 7 of 910 (0.8%) and home pages in 0 of 180. At these counts there is no meaningful difference between the groups.

Two things stand out in the list itself. 180 of the 2,098 URLs (8.6%) were bare home pages. A citation to a home page cannot support a specific claim in the answer, but it is still counted as a citation. And the 12 pages that returned 404 or 410 included a Product Hunt help article, an alternatives page on getguru.com and a pricing guide on casrai.org, all checked on 13 November 2026.

Why this matters for measurement

  • Dead links are not the main measurement problem. Under 1% of cited URLs were gone, so a citation count is not badly inflated by pages that vanished. The bigger uncertainty is elsewhere: one run is a sample, and answers change from run to run.
  • A checker cannot confirm about 1 URL in 13. 7.7% of cited URLs refused or ignored an automated request. Any tool that tries to confirm that its citations are real will hit that wall, so it should report the unverified share, not hide it.
  • Per-answer numbers follow citation volume. If you compare engines by "answers with a broken citation", you are mostly comparing how many links each engine cites.
  • Redirects matter. Four of the 16 lost citations ended on a home page. If you move or retire a page that AI cites, redirect it to its exact replacement, not to the home page.

What this cannot tell you

  • That the cited page supports the claim. We checked whether each address loads, not whether its content matches what the answer said.
  • That the pattern holds on another day or topic. This was a single run on software and AI tools, in English from the US, and the pages were checked 20 days later. Other topics, or a longer gap, may lose more.
  • What the unverified 7.7% are. Some may be fine for a human visitor, some may be dead.
  • Whether real users see the same citations. Our answers came from a data provider's live scrapes of each engine. For ChatGPT, 87 of 88 answers carried citations, which may be more than typical chats show.
  • Which page a citation led to at the time of the answer. We only saw the address.

What to do with it

  1. List the pages of yours that earn citations and check their status every month. A 404 on a page AI already trusts is a lost asset.
  2. Redirect moved pages to the exact new URL, not to your home page.
  3. Ask your tracking tool how it treats pages it cannot reach, and report the unverified share beside the citation count.
  4. Make sure AI crawlers can reach the pages you want cited. A page that blocks them cannot be checked or cited reliably.
  5. Repeat the check on a schedule. The share of missing pages grows with time.

Find the cited pages, check the sources, check access

Track which pages AI cites for you and your rivals. Visibility Overview in the AI Visibility Toolkit shows mentions, citations and the cited pages over time across AI platforms.

Semrush's own illustration of the Visibility Overview report in the AI Visibility Toolkit, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 9 October 2026): an AI Visibility score of 36/100, an "All AI platforms" selector, and mentions, citations and cited pages over six months. Semrush's illustration, not our account.
Semrush's own illustration of the Visibility Overview report in the AI Visibility Toolkit, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 9 October 2026): an AI Visibility score of 36/100, an "All AI platforms" selector, and mentions, citations and cited pages over six months. Semrush's illustration, not our account.

See what each cited page is doing for you. Prompt Tracking lists the sources that AI platforms cite for the prompts you track, with details for each cited page.

Semrush's own illustration of Cited page details in Prompt Tracking, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 29 October 2026): a Reddit thread cited for two running-shoe prompts, with suggestions for earning mentions from it, the brand's mention rate on that page (0%) and a mention marked "Lost". Semrush's illustration, not our account.
Semrush's own illustration of Cited page details in Prompt Tracking, from its Knowledge Base (retrieved 29 October 2026): a Reddit thread cited for two running-shoe prompts, with suggestions for earning mentions from it, the brand's mention rate on that page (0%) and a mention marked "Lost". Semrush's illustration, not our account.

Check that AI bots can reach your pages. Site Audit in the SEO Toolkit crawls a site as search engines and AI bots do and reports AI Search Health, including pages blocked from AI search bots.

Semrush's own illustration of the Site Audit overview, from its AI Search Health Knowledge Base page (retrieved 29 October 2026): a demo audit with JavaScript rendering disabled, Site Health 65%, crawled pages by status, an AI Search Health score of 58% and the pages blocked from AI search bots such as ChatGPT-User, OAI-SearchBot and Googlebot. Semrush's illustration, not our account.
Semrush's own illustration of the Site Audit overview, from its AI Search Health Knowledge Base page (retrieved 29 October 2026): a demo audit with JavaScript rendering disabled, Site Health 65%, crawled pages by status, an AI Search Health score of 58% and the pages blocked from AI search bots such as ChatGPT-User, OAI-SearchBot and Googlebot. Semrush's illustration, not our account.

The AI Visibility Toolkit has no free trial of its own; the 7-day free trial is Semrush One's, which includes it alongside the SEO Toolkit. To see which pages AI cites for your brand before paying, try Semrush One free for 7 days: its page offers "Unlimited access to all Semrush One tools", checked on 16 October 2026. Those are Semrush's published terms, not something we tested; none of the data above came from a Semrush account.

Semrush One's own product page: "Try free for 7 days" button with "Unlimited access to all Semrush One tools" beneath it. Captured from Semrush's page on 26 September 2026; the same wording was live on 16 October 2026.
Semrush One's own product page: "Try free for 7 days" button with "Unlimited access to all Semrush One tools" beneath it. Captured from Semrush's page on 26 September 2026; the same wording was live on 16 October 2026.
Semrush's official Semrush One graphic, from the Semrush Creator Accelerator affiliate resources: "Semrush One" at the centre of ten capabilities, including AI + SEO Visibility, Site Health + AI Search Auditing, AI Brand Narrative and Share of Voice. Semrush's own image.
Semrush's official Semrush One graphic, from the Semrush Creator Accelerator affiliate resources: "Semrush One" at the centre of ten capabilities, including AI + SEO Visibility, Site Health + AI Search Auditing, AI Brand Narrative and Share of Voice. Semrush's own image.

A citation is a promise about a page

The data says the promise is kept far more often than not, and that the part nobody can verify is bigger than the part that is broken. Count your citations, and report how many of them you could check.

Try Semrush One free for 7 days

Visibility Overview and Prompt Tracking to see which pages AI cites, with Site Audit's AI Search Health in the SEO Toolkit to check that AI bots can reach your pages, together in Semrush One. Free for 7 days for new users.

Try Semrush One free for 7 days

How we counted

  • Questions and engines: 88 questions about AI tools and software, each asked on ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Perplexity and Claude through DataForSEO, US location, on 24 October 2026. One answer per question per engine, 440 in all.
  • Citations: the web addresses listed as references in each answer, once per question and engine: 797 from ChatGPT, 873 from Perplexity, 494 from Claude, 286 from Gemini and 234 from Google AI Mode, 2,684 in total, with 2,098 unique URLs.
  • The check: every unique URL requested on 13 November 2026, with a HEAD request and a GET if the HEAD was refused, a 15-second timeout, up to five redirects and a browser-style User-Agent. Every URL that did not load, 276 in all, was tried again with curl and a 30-second timeout. A second Node request with a 30-second timeout recovered none of the 92 URLs that had not answered or had returned a server error.
  • Groups: loads (success status), gone (404 or 410, both clients agreeing), sent to a home page (a redirect that ends on a bare home page when a deeper page was cited), refused (401, 402, 403, 406 or 429), no answer or error (everything else).
  • Page types: from the address only. Comparison means "vs", "compare" or "alternative" in the path; best-of list means "best", "top" or "ranked" in the path; home page means a path of "/".
  • Not shown: the individual answers, the content of any page, and any measure of whether a cited page supports the claim.
  • Reproduce it: the scripts and the summary are in our research folder (research/r2-d1-citation-link-health/) and read the saved answers.

Explore More AI Tools

Browse our curated directory of 855+ verified AI tools.

Browse Directory

Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.